Boxers vs. Briefs vs. Boxer Briefs

Caveat Emptor Comparison Series: MEN'S UNDERWEAR

By Alexander S. Kabbaz, Custom Clothier & Haberdasher
Personal preference and comfort are the overriding arbiters here. That said, most men have at least a modicum of interest in how their choice will be perceived by their partner or spouse. You'll probably be extremely surprised at the disparity of opinions between men and women ... which is the opposite case when it comes to women's styles.

First, the definitions: There are three basic styles of men's underwear.

  • Boxer Shorts - made of fabric (woven - not stretchy) like that used for dress shirts
  • Boxer Briefs & Boxer Trunks - made of brief fabric (knitted - stretchy) in the length of boxers (Boxer Briefs) and with short legs (Boxer Trunks)
  • Briefs - Need I say more than Tighty Whities? (Although they are offered in many colors)

L. to R.: Boxer Shorts, Boxer Briefs, Briefs, Boxer Trunks

Click to Enlarge

Boxer Shorts, in cotton or silk, are considered the classic option. They are the "quintessential, elegant, and refined - not overly showy" style. Due to the looser fit, many consider them extremely comfortable to wear with the notable exception that there is often a lot of extra material in the pants. On the downside, they offer virtually no support which is considered important by many men.
Classic boxers scored in the top half with 25%-30% of women who cited their understated, classic, masculine style ... and for being different than women's usual styles.

Boxer Shorts

Boxer Shorts

Boxer Briefs and Trunks provide more support than classic boxers and are form-fitting rather than relaxed. Many find the snug fit and adherence to the body's movements more comfortable than the "extra fabric inside the pants" downside of classic boxers.
Boxer Briefs, and to a lesser extent, Boxer Trunks, were the preferred option of almost half of the opposite sex who regarded their form-fitting characteristics as an overwhelming plus.

Boxer Trunks (top) and Boxer Briefs (bottom)

Boxer Trunks (top) and Boxer Briefs (bottom)

Briefs are worn by more than 60% of men who regard their comfort, snug fit, and support as overwhelmingly important. As well, their "legless" construction creates no constriction during any form of movement.
However, briefs fall at the top of the "we simply don't agree" list. Less than 10% of women want to see their fellow in these. The reason most often cited lies in the similarity of men's briefs to women's bikini underwear. The majority of women overwhelmingly did not want to "picture him wearing my underwear".

Briefs

Briefs

Summing it up ... Men: 60% Briefs; Women: 90% anything but Briefs! And by the way, no matter which style you choose, know that there is no substitute for cotton, silk, or a plant-based organic synthetic such as micromodal. This is no place for petroleum-based synthetics such as polyester and microfiber or plastic based synthetic fibers like acrylic. Click here for a more in-depth study of preferred underwear styles.


Thank you for reading. Please don't hesitate to contact the author with questions or comments.
Copyright © 2018 Alexander Kabbaz. All rights reserved.